Emunah, Bitachon, and Hishtadlut
The Torah Balance of Faith, Trust, and Effort
When a family begins to consider aliyah, one conversation can hold both a longing to live in Eretz Yisrael and a practical question about paying the rent. A job loss or a difficult conversation with a relative can bring the same tension into an ordinary week. We want to trust Hashem, and we still have decisions to make. How do we know when to act, when we have done enough for now, and how to live with what remains uncertain?
Three Hebrew terms help us think about these questions. Emunah (אמונה) is faith in Hashem and the steadiness that comes from remembering Him. Bitachon (ביטחון) is trust in Hashem as we face what we cannot foresee. Hishtadlut (השתדלות) is the practical effort we make to meet our responsibilities. These are working definitions. The ideas overlap, and one decision can call for all three.
Emunah and the source of our strength
After the crossing of the sea, the Torah says that Israel saw what Hashem had done and believed in Him (Shemot 14:31). That moment gives us one way to recognize emunah. We see what has happened and remember whose hand is at work. In Devarim, Moshe addresses the Israelites before they enter a land where they will build homes and accumulate wealth. He anticipates what success can do to memory. A person may look at what he has built and conclude that his own strength produced it. Moshe tells the people to remember that Hashem gives them the power to acquire wealth.1
That final detail matters. The Torah acknowledges the power we exercise. We work, develop judgment, and make decisions that have consequences. Emunah asks us to remember the source of the very abilities we use. A person who has built a business can take satisfaction in years of honest work and also give thanks for the people, opportunities, and abilities that made the work possible. The moment after a success is as much an occasion to practice emunah as the moment before a difficult decision.
Bitachon while the answer is still unknown
Rabbeinu Bahya ibn Paquda opens Sha’ar HaBitachon, the Gate of Trust in Chovot HaLevavot, by describing the peace of mind that comes from relying on someone worthy of trust. Later, he discusses how a person can choose work suited to his abilities and pursue it while continuing to rely on Hashem for his livelihood.2
The Chazon Ish, Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz, addresses the uncertainty directly in Emunah U’Bitachon. He distinguishes trust in Hashem’s providence from certainty that events will turn out as we hope. Before a decision comes through, we can ask sincerely for the outcome we want. If the answer disappoints us, we can take time to absorb it and then decide how to respond.3
The words “Trust in GOD and do good” put trust and conduct together (Tehillim 37:3, Revised JPS). Rashi applies the verse to livelihood and charity. The pressure to provide for ourselves can tempt us to take what belongs to someone else or to stop helping people in need. Trust has a practical expression in both cases. It helps us earn honestly and remain generous within our means.4
Hishtadlut in the Torah and Gemara
When Yaakov learns that Esav is approaching with four hundred men, he divides his camp, prays for deliverance, and sends a gift ahead. Rashi says that Yaakov prepared a gift, prayed, and made himself ready to fight if necessary. Bereshit Rabbah also considers why the Torah describes Yaakov as both afraid and distressed. One reading sees him fearing for his own life and agonizing over the possibility that he might take a life himself. He has to weigh what could happen to his family and what his own response might cost.5
Yaakov’s example leaves room for several kinds of response to the same problem. When a family disagreement is brewing, prayer can help us steady ourselves. A private conversation may repair a misunderstanding. If previous conversations have broken down, asking a trusted person to help may be the next responsible step. Each action addresses a different part of the difficulty.
The Gemara in Berakhot 35b considers how to make a living while giving Torah study its place. Rabbi Yishmael reads the Torah’s instruction to gather grain as room for ordinary work. Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai asks what will become of Torah if the demands of plowing, planting, and harvesting fill the year. Abaye observes that many who followed Rabbi Yishmael’s approach succeeded, while many who tried Rabbi Shimon’s approach did not. Both sides of the discussion speak to a working household. Earning a living deserves time, and Torah study needs a regular place in the week before the calendar fills up.6
Some effort is a matter of protecting others. Devarim requires a parapet for the roof of a new house to prevent a fall. In Shabbat 32a, the Gemara describes Rabbi Yannai checking a crossing before he used it. He teaches that a person should avoid putting himself in danger on the assumption that a miracle will save him. A loose stair railing at home gives us a small, concrete application. Securing it is part of our responsibility to the people who use the stairs.7
What the widow already had
In II Kings, a widow tells Elisha that a creditor is coming to take her two sons. Elisha asks what she has in the house. She has a small supply of oil. At his direction she borrows vessels from her neighbors and pours the oil into them. The oil continues to flow until the vessels are filled. Elisha then tells her to sell it, pay the debt, and live on what remains.8
The Zohar reads Elisha’s question as a search for something on which divine blessing could rest. The little oil she already possessed was the beginning. The widow also had to ask her neighbors for vessels and do the pouring. The story prompts a practical question. What do I already have that I can put to work? For someone starting over, it might be a skill learned in a previous job, a person willing to make an introduction, or a few hours a week to learn something new.9
Putting the balance into practice
Looking for work
Set aside time to update your résumé, ask two people for introductions, and prepare for interviews. Make room in your tefillah for a specific request for parnassah, or livelihood. When an answer comes, consider what you can learn from it. A rejection may give you reason to seek feedback, widen the search, or ask someone to review how you describe your experience. After you have taken the steps you planned for the day, give yourself permission to return to the rest of your responsibilities.
Repairing a relationship
If you spoke sharply to a relative, start with the words you actually said. Acknowledge them, apologize plainly, and give the other person time to respond. Your effort is in making the apology and changing how you speak the next time. Bitachon can help you leave room for the other person to work through the hurt at their own pace.
Preparing for aliyah
Start with a family conversation about why you want to live in Israel and what each person would need to feel at home there. Put actual rental listings beside your housing estimate. Map an ordinary weekday from a neighborhood you are considering, including the trips to shul, work, or school that matter to your household. Try a regular Hebrew study session. Compare a month of normal spending with the one-time expenses of moving. Each of those steps gives you something concrete to discuss and may change the timing or shape of your plan.
Bring those specifics into your tefillah. Ask Hashem for clarity about where your family can build a life, and for patience if you need to revise the plan. If the numbers or a family obligation point to more preparation, decide what you can do now and when to review the decision together. The desire to make aliyah can give direction to that work even while the date is still open.
At the end of the day
Choose one matter that has been occupying your thoughts. Name one action you can take tomorrow. Then name the part that depends on someone else, on circumstances, or simply on time. Bring both into your tefillah. When tomorrow comes, take the step you named. When you sit down again to review the situation, let what actually happened guide the next one.
Source Notes
- Shemot (Exodus) 14:31 and Devarim (Deuteronomy) 8:11–18. Moshe describes prosperity in the land and calls on Israel to remember who gives them the power to acquire wealth. Exodus 14:31 · Deuteronomy 8 ↩
- Rabbeinu Bahya ibn Paquda, Chovot HaLevavot (Duties of the Heart), Sha’ar HaBitachon, chapters 1 and 3. The first chapter defines trust and the third discusses choosing and pursuing a livelihood. Chapter 1 · Chapter 3 ↩
- Rabbi Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz (the Chazon Ish), Emunah U’Bitachon, chapter 2, section 1. His discussion of providence and uncertain outcomes is paraphrased here. Hebrew text ↩
- Tehillim (Psalms) 37:3, quoted in the Revised JPS translation (2023), and Rashi ad loc., on honest livelihood and charity. Psalm 37:3 · Rashi ↩
- Bereishit (Genesis) 32:7–22 and Rashi on 32:9. See also Bereshit Rabbah 76:2, in the passage on Yaakov’s fear and distress. Sefaria’s online edition displays that passage as 76:8. Genesis 32 with Rashi · Midrash ↩
- Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 35b, the Gemara’s discussion of Devarim 11:14. Berakhot 35b ↩
- Devarim (Deuteronomy) 22:8 and Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 32a. Deuteronomy 22:8 · Shabbat 32a ↩
- Melakhim Bet (II Kings) 4:1–7. II Kings 4:1–7 ↩
- Zohar II, Yitro 87b, on Elisha’s question and the widow’s oil. See also Zohar I, Lech Lecha 87a, for a parallel discussion. Yitro 87b · Lech Lecha 87a ↩